Grass Lake
Trick or treat · Grass Lake
A blue toothbrush

Rare · about 1 in 210

A toothbrush

The dentist on the corner says hello. Floss, too.

Photo: Jonas Bergsten, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

You knocked. The door opened. You got what you got. Every visit hands out one thing at random, and some things are rarer than others.

The odds

What's in the bowl

Every visit draws one thing from this list. The draw happens on our end as the page loads, so it works with or without JavaScript, and nothing is stored: no cookies, no account, no count of how many times you've knocked. Rarer really is rarer. You can refresh all night and never see the full-size bar.

TreatOdds per knock
Common
A fun-size Snickersabout 1 in 12
A fun-size Kit Katabout 1 in 12
A Reese's Peanut Butter Cupabout 1 in 12
A Tootsie Rollabout 1 in 12
A little bag of candy cornabout 1 in 12
A roll of Smartiesabout 1 in 12
A Dum Dums popabout 1 in 12
Fun-size M&M'sabout 1 in 12
Fun-size Skittlesabout 1 in 12
A Starburst two-packabout 1 in 12
Uncommon
A fun-size Twixabout 1 in 41
A fun-size Milky Wayabout 1 in 41
An Almond Joyabout 1 in 41
Sour Patch Kidsabout 1 in 41
A mini box of Nerdsabout 1 in 41
A Laffy Taffyabout 1 in 41
A carton of Whoppersabout 1 in 41
Rare
A toothbrushabout 1 in 210
An appleabout 1 in 210
A mini box of raisinsabout 1 in 210
A snack bag of pretzelsabout 1 in 210
A handful of penniesabout 1 in 210
Very rare
A glow stickabout 1 in 1,000
The whole bowl, unattendedabout 1 in 1,000
Legendary
A full-size candy barabout 1 in 1,600

Photos are by the Wikimedia Commons photographers credited below. The candy names and packaging belong to the companies that make them, none of which had anything to do with this page. Odds are rounded.

Photo credits
Out on the loop after dark? Watch for cars on the road stretches, and please keep the wrappers out of the water. The wood ducks don't want your Smarties.